Silent auctions are a fantastic way to raise funds, engage supporters, and add excitement to charity events. Whether you’re hosting a gala dinner, corporate fundraiser, or community event, a well-run silent auction can bring in impressive donations, while offering guests a fun and rewarding experience.
But as with any fundraising activity, success depends on getting the details right. Even small mistakes can lead to missed bids, disengaged guests, or underperforming prizes.
Here are 5 common mistakes that people make at silent auctions and how to avoid them so that your next auction goes smoothly and delivers maximum impact.
-
Poor Item Selection
Mistake: Offering prizes that don’t excite your audience.
Solution: Know your guests and choose prizes that align with their interests.
Silent auctions work best when the items on offer genuinely appeal to your audience. Too often, events include donated items that feel like filler. Think outdated electronics, generic gift baskets, or overly niche services. These don’t inspire competitive bidding and often go unsold.
Instead, focus on experience-based auction prizes that create a buzz: VIP hospitality packages, weekend getaways, signed memorabilia, or exclusive dining experiences. At Impulse Decisions, we specialise in curating bespoke auction prizes that are proven to spark interest and drive bidding wars.
-
Lack of Promotion Before the Event
Mistake: Waiting until the night of the event to showcase your auction items.
Solution: Build anticipation with early previews and digital access.
Guests are far more likely to bid when they know what’s on offer and they’ve had time to get excited about it. Don’t leave promotion to the last minute. Use your email list, social media, and event invitations to showcase key items ahead of time.
Better yet, consider using a digital silent auction platform that lets guests browse and bid from their phones, even before the event begins. This can significantly boost engagement and bidding activity.
-
Overcomplicating the Bidding Process
Mistake: Making bidding difficult or unclear.
Solution: Keep the process simple, user-friendly, and well-explained.
Guests are less likely to bid if they don’t know how to do it or have to wait in line to do it. Using paper bid sheets can work, but they can also cause problems, especially at bigger events.
We suggest using mobile bidding platforms that let guests bid at their own pace. Make sure your presenter explains everything at the beginning and has staff available to answer questions. More bids and more money raised come from a smooth bidding process.
-
Not Highlighting High-Value Prizes
Mistake: Treating all auction items the same.
Solution: Shine a spotlight on your star items.
Every auction has a few standout prizes, just make sure everyone knows about them. Give them prime placement in your auction display, feature them in your promotional materials, and mention them during speeches.
Better visibility means more competition, which leads to better returns. You might even consider running a live auction for one or two top-tier prizes to build excitement and raise more on the night.
-
Failing to Follow Up Post-Event
Mistake: Forgetting to thank your bidders and donors.
Solution: Show appreciation and stay connected.
Once the event is over, the work isn’t done. Always follow up with winning bidders to confirm item delivery, answer questions, and thank them for their generosity. The same goes for anyone who donated prizes.
Following up in a thoughtful way builds relationships and makes it more likely that they will come to your next event. You can also use this time to get feedback and testimonials that will help you plan future auctions.
Silent auctions can be a powerful fundraising idea but only when executed properly. By avoiding these common mistakes and focusing on audience experience, smart promotion, and curated prizes, you’ll be well on your way to a successful event.
At Impulse Decisions, we help charities, organisations, and corporate hosts run smooth silent auctions with high-value, experience-based prizes that get people talking and bring in the most donations.
Contact our team today to find out how we can help you with your next charity event by offering customised auction packages and expert advice at every stage.